Rogerian Argument Assignment

For our third essay, we are going to write a Rogerian argument.  A Rogerian argument is especially useful when addressing issues that are controversial enough that it is difficult to persuade an audience of your own views. In this way, a Rogerian argument better approximates the compromise of real life than more standard argumentation styles.   The following are the characteristics of Rogerian argument:

 

·        
It avoids a confrontational stance by establishing common ground with the opposing view.

·        
It presents your perspective as reasonable and understanding (and thus credible) because you appear willing to modify your views.

·        
It ultimately works toward a compromise or workable solution.

 

 

How is the Rogerian approach formatted?

1)     
The introduction: (one paragraph)  The issue you want to address is objectively defined and explained in the introduction. It is important for the writer to explain the context and historical background of the issue.  You could use sources in this paragraph to explain the issue. As in other argumentative essays, a thesis statement delineating the points of your stance is required, but this thesis statement will also acknowledge the opposing view.

 

2)     
Presentation of the opposition’s view: (one or two paragraphs)   In this section, the writer should present the opposing viewpoint by providing details about how and why it is valid in some contexts. It is important for the writer to use a neutral and non-judgmental tone in this section.  Sources and examples that explain the opposition’s point of view are helpful.

 

 

3)     
Presentation of the writer’s view: (two paragraphs)   This section presents the writer’s own views in a neutral manner. It is also important to present the contexts in which this view is valid. Sources and examples that explain the writers’s point of view are useful.

 

 

4)     
Analysis of both views: (one paragraph) This is where the writer evaluates what the two sides have in common and what values both share. Here, the writer can ask the following question: “On what can my opponent and I agree on?”

 

 

5)     
Proposal of a solution / conclusion: (one paragraph) This solution should take into account the interests and concerns of both sides. This conclusion should explain how the proposed solution will satisfy both sides.  If relevant and available, sources that attest to the viability of your proposed solution are helpful.